Reading Approaches of Bottom-up and Top-down Essay

Reading Approaches of Bottom-up and Top-down The main two approaches to reading, top-down and bottom-up have produced a great debate towards which is the best approach to teach children to read. Top down reading is also known as the whole language approach in which the meaning of the text relies upon the reader’s background knowledge and his/her use of prediction to anticipate the meaning of the text. (http://www.sedl.org/reading/topics/balanced.html [23.10.01]). The bottom-up approach to reading involves the use of phonics and the decoding of text, word by word after which meaning and understanding will follow (http://www.sedl.org/reading/topics/balanced.html [23.10.01]). Phonics is†¦show more content†¦Let us first examine the positive contributions and limitations of each approach. Goodman, (1971) a top-down theorist, describes reading as a pscholinguistic guessing game (p.135) and he stresses that readers benefit by making predictions from their knowledge to understand their reading (Goodman, 1973 in Carrell, 1988a) (http://langue.hyper.chubu.ac.jp/jalt/pub/tlt/99/jan/frehan.html [16.10.01]). Paul Abraham, in his article Field Notes states that the bottom-up approach in comparison does not recognise what students can contribute to the reading material. (http://www.sabes.org/f02abrah.htm [16.10.01]) Padraic Frehan of the British Council English school of Tokyo comments that the bottom-up approach reveals problems like fragmentation of words and overload of memory due to keeping a lot of separate bits of information in the mind without any higher order connection between the separate pieces of information (Carrell, 1988b) (http://langue.hyper.chubu.ac.jp/jalt/pub/tlt/99/jan/frehan.html [16.10.01]). This shows that the bottom-up approach has limitations but let us observe how this approach can benefit children’s reading. Phonics can be applied to using rhymes which is a way of developing phonological awareness (â€Å"theShow MoreRelatedEvaluation Of A Evaluation Policy Evaluation816 Words   |  4 Pagesorganization lack when engaging in evaluation is transparency of evaluation policies. By not disclosing their evaluation policies it can not be replicated or understood by new organization members. In addition, creates a way for organizations to make up policies without getting feedback about evaluation best practices. Trochim (2009) noted that evaluation policies are important to communicate mechanism on what evaluation should be done, what resources expended and how they they should be accomplishedRead MoreThe Top Down Approach And The Bottom Up Approach1236 Words   |  5 Pagessemester we have read several articles and chapters with the reoccurring theme of the top-down approach and the bottom-up approach. We were initial ly introduced to the approaches through the articles How Does it Work? Policy Implementation (Smith Larimar, 2009), Implementing Public Policy (Hill Hupe, 2002) and Implementation and Public Policy chapter 2 (Mazmanian Sabatier, 1983). According to the readings, the top-down model starts with a policy decision and examine the extent to which its legallyRead MoreReading Models Are Vital For Twenty First Century Classrooms Essay1545 Words   |  7 PagesReading models are vital to twenty first centaury classrooms, as they become an important tool for teachers, that are teaching their students reading as well as writing(Goodman,1997).Reading ultimately becomes an interaction between what a reader has learnt, and the information that is already in the text. This essay will be touching on the top down approach to reading, and how this is a vital tool to twenty first century classrooms. All the while showing how this is used in classroom practice. Read MoreAnalysis Of Alfred Binet And Lewis Terman On Intelligence Testing1696 Words   |  7 Pages1. When comparing Alfred Binet and Lewis Terman on their approaches to intelligence testing there are some similarities amongst the two. One such similarity would be regarding content. Alfred Binet’s approach to intelligence testing consisted of tests that ranged in difficulty levels from easy to hard. These tests required one to demonstrate his or her own cognitive ability, decision making, and verbal skills. Lewis Terman’s approach to intelligence testing was an updated version of Binet’s. TermanRead MoreA Review on Reading Theories and Its Implication to the Teaching of Reading5137 Words   |  21 PagesA REVIEW ON READING THEORIES AND IT’S IMPLICATION TO THE TEACHING OF READING Parlindungan Pardede Universitas Kristen Indonesia Abstract Opini dan masukan untuk peningkatan pengajaran membaca kepada pembelajar bahasa Inggris sebagai bahasa asing, baik yang didasarkan pada hasil penelitian maupun pengalaman, tersedia sangat banyak dalam kepustakaan pengajaran bahasa. Tulisan ini merupakan sebuah rangkuman atas berbagai teori, temuan dan pendapat tentang pengajaran membaca. Pemahaman terhadap topik-topikRead MoreEducator Application Essay982 Words   |  4 Pagessetting), I taught vocabulary, grammar, reading skills, and structures of essays through readings deriving from the news, articles in magazines, short fiction and non-fiction, and models of essays. In order to effectively teach them, I selected the content of reading materials that were relevant to their English levels and lives so they were able to utilize their prior knowledge to assist them in understanding the texts and be motivated during their reading process. During teaching, I employed theRead MoreSupporting Literacy for All Children1014 Words   |  5 Pages There are many theories surrounding education and what lies within our biological functions that can effect how we learn as human beings. Our book, Creating Literacy Instruction For All Students, by Thomas Gunning goes more in depth of these approaches and theories. Behaviorism is a theory that â€Å"stresses observable responses to stimuli†. This approach includes conditioning good behaviors and eliminating unwanted behaviors (Gunning, 4). Another major theory surrounding learning is cognitivism,Read MoreActions of Living Changes Heart Rate Essay603 Words   |  3 Pagesmammals, specifically whales and other diving marine mammals have the ability to induce a mechanism called Bradycardia, intentionally slowing their heart rate down during a dive. The decrease of heart rate is beneficial because the heart is pumping slower, working less, and consuming less oxygen during the dive. When the mammal approaches the surface it induces anticipatory tachycardia to raise the heart rat e back to normal levels. (University of Miami 2013) A heart rate is the frequency of yourRead MoreFive Key Ideas About Quality Assessment1068 Words   |  5 Pagesquality assessment measures. The following paper identifies five key aspects of what constitutes quality assessment. We are reminded that the goal of testing is in ‘building proficiency in basic skills, closing achievement gaps, and fostering the top notch knowledge and skills that students will need in a competitive global society’ (Scherer, 2009, p. 5). Therefore, standardised tests alone are not an adequate benchmark in determining a student’s ability to learn. McMillan (2007) emphasises theRead MoreA Brief History of Time Summary Essay1371 Words   |  6 Pagesdescribed by a cone. The top of the cone represents the future path of light, the bottom half of the cone represents the past path of the light, while the central vertex represents the actual light. In the third chapter, Hawking takes upon the continuous and accelerated expansion of the universe. In order to prove this, he uses the â€Å"Doppler shift† which is almost identical to the Doppler Effect. In sound, the Doppler Effect creates an increasingly louder sound as the event approaches us, and then as the